Pick Your Poison After Dark + Expansion Set — Adult Party Card Game for White Elephant & Gift Nights

Elevate Your Party with Pick Your Poison After Dark

Dive into a bold, fully reusable party experience where two Poison prompts collide to create one outrageous scenario. The After Dark edition, paired with the expansion, invites players to weigh cheeky and daring choices, sparking candid conversations and plenty of laughs—without pressuring anyone to decide for you.

What’s inside and how it works

With the base game and expansion, you’ll have access to a total of 400 scenario cards. By pairing two cards, players craft inventive and provocative hypotheticals that others must respond to, making each round feel fresh and unpredictable.

• 400 scenario cards across base + expansion for thousands of combos
• 3–10 players; ages 15+, sessions typically 30–60 minutes
• After Dark edition adds spicier prompts for bolder, more flavorful play

Perfect for gatherings and gift-worthy moments

• Ideal for White Elephant, Friendsgiving, Secret Santa, and holiday parties
• Compact, easily giftable packaging that fits in a stocking or under the tree
• Fun for adults and friends looking to break the ice and share a few genuine laughs

Tips for playing: start with lighter prompts to warm up, then blend in After Dark cards for more daring options. Read the room, keep the mood friendly, and view the choices as engaging conversation starters rather than guarantees of outcomes.